The ICE’s latest report explains how better public engagement can improve infrastructure delivery and rebuild public trust.
Britain has an infrastructure delivery problem, a growth problem and, increasingly, a trust problem.
We are not building enough of the infrastructure needed to support economic growth, achieve net zero and improve resilience.
Projects take too long. Costs increase. Public confidence in decision-making is often weak.
Too often, these challenges are treated separately. Our new report, A Mandate to Build, argues they are closely connected.
Our argument is not a case for slowing down development, but a vision for improving how decisions are made and importantly, how communities are involved.
Why we need better public engagement
Better public engagement can help deliver infrastructure faster, cheaper and with greater support.
The question isn’t whether communities should have a voice, but when, where and how that voice is heard.
This debate matters because the UK is entering a period of significant infrastructure investment.
Hundreds of billions of pounds are expected to be invested in energy networks, transport systems, water infrastructure and digital connectivity over the coming decade.
At the same time, government is reforming the planning system, devolving power to strategic authorities and exploring new approaches to consultation and participation.
Together, these changes create a rare opportunity to rethink how the public is involved in infrastructure decisions.
A Mandate to Build
The ICE and Future Governance Forum have partnered to examine how public engagement can support, rather than hold back, delivery.
The result is A Mandate to Build, a new framework for infrastructure planning that seeks to strengthen public trust without creating new barriers to development.
At the heart of the problem is a simple contradiction.
The current system asks communities to engage most intensively at the point when many of the most important decisions have already been made.
Public participation is concentrated at the project level, when discussions are often highly technical and focused on the details of a scheme.
By that stage, many of the strategic decisions that shape outcomes – whether infrastructure is needed, what type of infrastructure should be built and the trade-offs involved – have largely been settled elsewhere. This creates frustration for everyone involved.
It’s not about more or less consultation
Communities feel they are being consulted on decisions they have little role in shaping.
Developers face opposition that often reflects disagreements about wider strategic questions rather than the project itself.
Consultation becomes adversarial, and trust becomes harder to establish.
The result is often the worst of all worlds: delays, higher costs and communities who feel they haven’t been heard.
The answer is not more consultation at every stage. Nor is it less consultation.
It's better consultation.
That means engagement taking place at the right level, at the right geography and on questions where public input can genuinely make a difference.
4 changes to improve public engagement
1. We should engage earlier
National decisions about infrastructure priorities should be informed by modern forms of public participation, including representative deliberative processes such as citizens' assemblies.
These approaches allow members of the public to consider evidence, weigh trade-offs and contribute to decisions before debates become polarised around individual projects.
If people are expected to support major infrastructure investment, they should have greater opportunities to shape the national conversation about what is needed and why.
2. We should strengthen the role of mayors and strategic authorities
As England moves towards a system of stronger strategic authorities, there’s an opportunity to create a clearer regional tier of infrastructure decision-making.
Regional leaders are often better placed than Whitehall to understand local priorities, mediate competing interests and build public legitimacy.
A stronger strategic layer can help bridge the gap between national need and local delivery.
3. Project-level consultation should be clearer and more honest
Too often, consultation exercises leave people uncertain about what is actually up for discussion.
Communities should be given a clearer account of what has already been decided, what remains open to influence and how public feedback will be used.
Being explicit about these distinctions would help create more meaningful engagement and focus debate on the issues that are genuinely still to be resolved.
4. Communities should feel the benefits of hosting nationally important infrastructure
At present, the planning system is largely designed to compensate communities for the impacts of development. It does much less to ensure they share in the benefits.
We propose a new Strategic Infrastructure Community Levy to ensure places that host nationally significant infrastructure see tangible local gains from doing so.
If communities are being asked to support projects that deliver national benefits, it's reasonable that they should also see local benefits in return.
Don’t just secure public trust at the end, build it throughout
Taken together, these reforms would create a fairer and more effective system of public participation.
They would not add new hurdles to infrastructure delivery. Instead, they would help establish consent earlier, give communities greater clarity about how decisions are made and strengthen accountability at every stage of the process.
Most importantly, they recognise that trust isn’t something that can be secured at the end of a planning process. It must be built throughout it.
Too often, infrastructure is experienced as something done to communities rather than with them. When that happens, opposition hardens, confidence in institutions declines and projects become harder to deliver.
Britain can’t afford that outcome.
If we want faster delivery, stronger growth and better infrastructure, we need a planning system that brings the public into the conversation sooner, more meaningfully and on the questions that matter most.
You may also be interested in@headerSize>

- Type
- Infrastructure blog
Devolution, ambition, and public control: reflections on Burnham’s first 90 days as PM
Andy Burnham has brought an injection of energy into Britain’s top job. But what does his tenure spell for infrastructure?

- Type
- Infrastructure blog
Why the CMA's civil engineering market study is a once-in-a-generation opportunity
It will take more than a strategy paper to change the fortunes of the sector. Mike Reader MP explains why the Competition and Markets Authority's recent study could lead to real change.

- Type
- Infrastructure blog
What architecture is getting right about inclusive design
The Royal Institute of British Architects' (RIBA) has shared best practice that the infrastructure sector can apply in its work.